Neverending Vanilla Extract (Make Your Own!)
Those of you who know me know that I have a serious make-your-own streak. (Think marshmallows, pomegranate molasses, hot sauce, hot chocolate mix, etc.) It’s so satisfying to make certain things at home—and so much fun. Here’s how to make your own vanilla extract. All you need is a nice bottle, your favorite vodka, and a few vanilla beans. You just can’t beat the flavor—and a bottle makes a great gift for anyone who likes to bake.
The Mouse’s homemade vanilla extract
How exactly is this vanilla extract “neverending,” Mouse?
Good question. (And no, it’s not magic—though it kinda seems like it.)
Because it’s made with vodka and vanilla beans, you can keep your bottle going for years by replenishing the vodka and vanilla beans as you use the extract.
Vanilla beans in my bottle of extract
I’ve had my bottle going since 2002. It’s bordering on becoming a family heirloom, right along with my sourdough starter.
What is vanilla extract, anyways?
Now I’m talking about the real deal here. (No boring bottles of imitation vanilla need apply.) Vanilla extract is just what it sounds like: vanilla beans soaked in alcohol until the booze extracts their flavorful goodness.
A freshly made bottle of vanilla extract
These days, it’s hard to find a good vanilla extract that has strong, true flavor—and doesn’t cost a million bucks.
Did you know?
Vanilla is one of the most expensive spices in the world after saffron, mainly due to how manually intensive production is. The plants are pollinated by hand, and take about five years from the time they are planted before the beans are ready for market.
Vanilla beans
Penzey’s, my favorite spice shop, carries their own brand of vanilla, in a couple different strengths and varieties. Their double-strength extract has fantastic flavor, but, as of this writing, costs about $46 for a 16 oz. bottle. That’s a steep investment for one ingredient, especially since I do a fair amount of baking.
You can see why it seemed reasonable to try making my own.
Ingredients and timing for vanilla extract
- I make my vanilla extract with vodka, but I know some folks who swear by rum.
- I recommend using 2 vanilla beans here, but honestly, you could certainly use more.
- It takes about 6-8 weeks for your extract to develop a dark color and really good flavor. As it ages, the flavor will only improve.
Neverending Vanilla Extract
1 glass bottle with lid, washed with hot, soapy water
1-2 cups of vodka, depending on the size of your bottle
2 vanilla beans
Grab your vanilla beans.
And your sterilized bottle. (I used a glass hot sauce bottle that I washed well with hot, soapy water.)
Be sure to pick a bottle that’s tall enough to fit your vanilla beans.
Insert the vanilla beans into your bottle.
Set a funnel in the mouth of the bottle.
Pour in the vodka.
Fill the bottle just to about the top.
Cap your bottle tightly and give it a shake. You should see little flecks of vanilla happily floating around in the vodka.
And now? You wait. Keep your extract on the counter in a cool, dark place (it doesn’t need to go in the fridge). Shake your vanilla extract every few days. It should be ready to use in about 6-8 weeks. If you want to speed up the process, use more vanilla beans.
As time passes, your extract will get darker and stronger.
Once you start using it, replenish it from time to time with fresh vanilla beans and more vodka.
Happy baking!
Related posts:
- 12 Last-Minute Homemade Holiday Gifts So, if you're like me this year, you might be...
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
42 Comments
this is fantastic! I had no idea that you can make vanilla extract right at home. I’m tired of buying vanilla extract that costs an arm.. or an arm or leg if you want the best one.
I’m actually very excited because this means I’ll have vanilla extract for years to come lol
Yay! Let me know how it comes out!
+Jessie
Jessie,
I love this and really appreciate your do it yourself recipes.I use vanilla a lot.Breakfast shakes and fruit salad dressing made with yogurt.Germany has a vanilla sugar but it hasn’t got the real strong flavor of the bean.You can buy the vanilla bean and of course VODKA!
SO NOW- I will definitely make this and be able to have it here and in Stuttgart.
Thank you so much !
Oh fantastic! (Ya know…you can also make your own vanilla sugar…bury a few vanilla beans in a jar of sugar and let it sit for a while…)
+Jessie
I love vanilla! Thanks for this amazing post!
Hehe, thanks Meg! You should definitely give it a try…especially because you love to bake!
+Jessie
I’ve always meant to make my own vanilla extract. Not sure what has been stopping me.
Hehe. If you’re anything like me, you have a list a mile long of stuff you need to make.
Hope you like it!
+Jessie
I love this kind of D.I.Y. stuff! It’s the only way to affordably get richly flavored vanilla at the quality you need (plus it’s a nice way to culinarily connect with the past).
Thanks, Doug! Totally agree about connecting with the past.
Yay.
+Jessie
This is a great post! I love to see how sauces are made.
Thanks so much!
+Jessie
I HAVE to try this! I think I’ll try both rum and vodka, to see which I like better. I’m not normally a vodka fan, but I’d think the flavor of the vanilla would be truer in vodka vs. rum.
Thanks, Kelly! I agree that vodka would give you a cleaner flavor. Let me know if you try the rum, though.
+Jessie
I love your series of photos! I work for The Spice House (original parent of Penzeys), so I’m lucky to have cheap access to high-quality vanilla extract, but I like making my own variations. Mexican beans in brandy, for example, are wonderful for heavily spices baked goods (or little nips straight from the bottle), and Tahitian beans in light rum make an extract perfect for fruit sauces. DIY extract is a great way to get around the unfortunate high price of good extract without having to resort to (shudder) imitation.
Hi Paige!
Thanks for stopping by! Ya know, I’ve heard of you guys, but haven’t ordered from you yet. (That will have to change…I’m such a fan of Penzey’s!)
Thanks for the great ideas.
+Jessie
I’ve pondered making my own in the past but wondered if it was really cheaper, after buying booze and vanilla beans. But I have a bunch of beans I’m not sure I’ll use up before they dry up, so I think I’ll give this a try.
Do you split the beans before you put them in, or just leave them whole?
Oh, I think it’s totally cheaper in the long run, provided you’re not using the most expensive vodka available.
I’ve never split the beans before putting them in, although I’m not sure why. I just always toss them in whole.
Let me know if you give it a whirl?
Thanks!
+Jessie
I do the same but with the cheapest vodka i can find and i also don’t split the beans. turns out beautifully. learned this trick from a chef in the w village.
Do you leave the older beans in after adding new ones? After adding new beans and vodka, do you have to wait another 6-8 weeks? I don’t know if I can go that long without baking
Hey Sarah!
Thanks for stopping by!
I do leave the beans in after adding new ones. I’m sure that they reach a point where their flavor is spent…but some of my beans have been in my bottle for years and the extract is just fine.
I usually top my bottle off once I’ve used maybe about a third of it. If you wait until your bottle is really empty to add more vodka, you’ll wind up with a really diluted extract. If you add a little bit here and a little bit there, you won’t be “watering” it down as much, if that makes sense, and you can pretty much keep baking as normal.
Let me know how it goes!
+Jessie
Beautiful pictures…I think I’ll try this, of course the only vodka I have is Grey Goose!
Wheee! Thanks! And if you make this with Grey Goose, you’ll certainly wind up with a top-shelf vanilla extract.
If you don’t want to use that, a bottle of something a little less expensive (provided, of course, that you like the flavor) will probably do you just fine.
+Jessie
Though it’s a bit pricey to buy the pods, it’s probably cheaper making vanilla at home (and less chemical) in the long run. Thanks for sharing!
Hehe, you hit the nail on the head. It is cheaper in the long run…and you get to control the quality. Let me hunt around online a bit and see if I can find a good source for inexpensive vanilla beans.
OH, if you have Trader Joes in your neck of the woods, they’ve had really good prices on beans in the past.
+Jessie
AHA! I see –
right along the sourdough line!
We still need to make that sourdough starter exchange, Jessie!
cheers!
gabi.
That is AWESOME. We are DEFINITELY going to try this!! I never would have thought you could make your own. LOVE it!!
This looks absolutely great!
I assume vanilla extract is more convenient to use as to scratch out fresh vanilla beans?
I thought about it – if you have anything barrel aged in the house, it could turn out even more fantastic.
Oak barrels tend to flavor the spirit inside into a primary vanilla, secondary caramel, toffee, light coffee flavor.
I would suggest a nice subtle barrel aged rum like Bacardi 8 or a not too spicy Bourbon [Maker's Mark].
Off course then it is not that cheap anymore – but still cheaper than store bought extract and of course much soperior…
Fantastic Jessie, I will certainly try this.
I gather there isn’t a ‘use by’ date on any of this the fact you can keep topping it up indefinitely.
This is awesome. I love to bake, and will be making some of my own vanilla soon. Don’t laugh when I ask this..but do i purchase the vanilla beans from the bakery aisle, or the produce department..I guess I have never seen them before in a store.
I’ve bought a Vodka and I was planing to stuff the beans into the buttle itself just like I saw on lots of recipies.
However, when I opened the buttle I saw that it has pouring spout that prevents me from stuffing the beans into the buttle.
I bought Nemiroff Premium, but I’ve looked at an Absolute Vodka buttle that was left from my sister’s bachelor party and it also has it.
The recipe that I saw used Finlandia, but it also said that Absolute is good as well.
Am I missing something??
Can the pouring spout can be removed?
I’ve guessing that Finlandia didn’t have that spout at the time the recepie was written and now it has became a standard.
Any help/information about how to easily remove the spout (if that even possible) will be welcome.
10x
I loved this idea and tried it. It’s been two months and still isn’t very dark so I split the beans hoping to try that. Anyone else have luck with theirs? I’m going to start another batch for christmas gifts and was wondering.
Hey Jess,
Thanks so much for reporting in. Splitting the beans might help. Or even adding another bean.
I’ll take a picture of mine tonight…the one that I started for this article. It’s not very dark, either, but the flavor should be pretty good–and will get even better over time. Like I said, I’ve had my big bottle going for a very long time…
+Jessie
Ah, this is fantastic! I’m always aggravated at the prices of extracts in the stores. Have made other extracts using this method? Like mint maybe?
that is totally awesome…thank you so much!!!!
I started making my own vanilla out of necessity – in order to make it gluten and corn free I use 100% potato vodka like Cold River. Yum.
We have been making our own extract for years. So much better and cheaper than the store bought stuff! I go back and forth, sometimes I split my beans, other times I cut them into 1″ pieces before putting them into silver (clear) rum. Personally I like the rum better than vodka, but either one (as well as brandy) will work. I put 3-4 beans in a 750ml bottle and let it site for 2-3 months. When we get to the end of a bottle, we freeze the leftover beans and scrape them in the summer when making ice cream. I get beans from Beanilla, about $65 for 100 beans (shipped). So, So good!
You can also make a great gift for the drinking buddies on your list. Into a 750ml bottle of rum place 1 vanilla bean (split), 1 cinnamon stick, and 6 cloves. Let this sit for at least one month, preferrably 2-3 months. Yummy!
commercial vanilla extract says that it is 5% alcohol. Does this mean that they dilute the vodka/vanilla that is made the way you suggest with 95% water? I have made bottles of “Tia Maria” and a few other cordials by adding vodka, simple syrup, and flavoring, like oranges, lemons, mint and cocoa. This is such a wonderful idea. I like to take lowfat plain yogurt and put the vanilla extract in it because when the manufacturers do it they start adding sugar and other things as preservatives which defeats the purpose.
Came across your site while looking for something else. That was about a day ago, and I’m still lurking around.
Great site; great content! I had no idea I could make my own extract. Now I need some baking ideas so I can use up my existing stash… and then get started on using my own. Thank you!